Oh, man, that pains me to look at it. I'm sure someone from the company would be willing the ship a replacement package...?
It's that buttery yellow. It makes it look like a Blu-Ray lolly.
I hate to admit but I used to chew on VHS covers in my youth. I'm talking about 5-7 years old. It must have been a teeth strengthening thing but I'd just pick a case up and chew on it...I kinda get where your son's at lol