I've noticed that "My little Eye" isn't exactly loved universally in the horror community, but I find it to be absolutely brilliant and frightening.
I also have a real liking for "Blairwitch 2: Book of Shadows"
, which is one of THE single most underrated horror sequels of all time to me- probably due to it being rushed out after the original's hype had just about gotten on everybody's nerves...
There's a lot I like about "Pet Sematary Two"- though I have to admit that it lost some of its appeal to me over the course of the last 20 years since I watched it about 4 times at the cinema and countless times on vhs...
I also rate "Leatherface: The Texas Chainsaw Massacre III" higher than "TCM 2" on my private scale.... at least it's the one I find myself watching far more often despite all its obvious faults and troubles, particularly concerning the finale...
And while we are at it: I DO consider "Stepfather III" to be a worthwhile watch!
