Ian McCulloch Audio Commentary

[ArgentoFan1987]

I was just wondering if anyone knew if the Ian McCulloch commentary that was on the American Blue Underground release, was on the new Arrow release.

[Daemonia]

Why? It's not a very good commentary and the moderator (a certain Mr Slater) lets McCulloch ramble on about everything except the bloody film you're watching. Very poor commentary IMO.

[Hammer time]

its on the UK box of the banned dvd

[ArgentoFan1987]

I wanted to know for these reasons three:

1. I've always been interested in commentaries in general
2. Interested in what McCulloch had to say about Zombie Flesh Eaters
3. I was slightly disappointed that the only other two Arrow DVD's I own (Terror at the Opera and Phenomena) were without commentaries

[Pete]

Originally Posted by Hammer time

its on the UK box of the banned dvd

It's not. It is on the the first US dvd from Anchor Bay and the Shriek Show edition.

[Andra Jai]

I actually thought Ian had some good things to say on the commentary, pity I can't say the same about his companion who pretty much had nothing to say and was saying it too loudly.

[James Morton]

Originally Posted by sam tyler

I actually thought Ian had some good things to say on the commentary, pity I can't say the same about his companion who pretty much had nothing to say and was saying it too loudly.

his 'companion' Jason Slater who i read had something to do with the crap Vipco a long time ago
have read a lot of his film reviews in THE DARK SIDE mag and imo comes across as a smug git

[ArgentoFan1987]

Originally Posted by James Morton

i have read many reviews by Slater and naturally there are some i actually agree with
but him saying something like 'watching VIDOCQ was like looking through candy wrappers'' or something
VIDOCQ is brilliant and one of my all time fave fims and not the above description
he has criticied other films/directors etc and most times i disagree with him

he is a film critic and they are just guides
a bit like all of us on this forum!
but Slater comes across as an arrogant sod

What is VIDOCQ?

[James Morton]

Originally Posted by ArgentoFan1987

What is VIDOCQ?

VIDOCQ ia a brilliant supernatural horror/fantasy thriller
the first feature film to be shot on hi def digital
made in 2000 it stars Gerard Depardieu
got the French TF1 2xdisc

[ArgentoFan1987]

Originally Posted by James Morton

VIDOCQ ia a brilliant supernatural horror/fantasy thriller
the first feature film to be shot on hi def digital
made in 2000 it stars Gerard Depardieu
got the French TF1 2xdisc

Cheers