| ||||
Now that we're on the topic of adaptions - FROM BEYOND - It just isn't possible to adapt H P Lovecraft for the big screen. You'd have thought people would have got that by now. The essence of his prose is IN the prose – a good deal of its weight is carried by his over-ripe but evocative style. And the rest of it is down to abstraction, the mind rending horror of the unnamable, the infinite et cetera et cetera. Two good arguments there for his work staying on the page and remaining indwelling inside the mind. Still, hopeful filmmakers haven't exactly been put off from trying over the years, and the list of unworthy Lovecraft adaptions is long enough to rival that of the other notoriously hard-done-to-by-film horror pro, Steven King, a writer who lends himself to a much more direct visual realisation than Lovecraft. It's no coincidence that the better Lovecraft translations have been based on his less typical works – 'Reanimator', for example. Many attempts on the cannon have failed. Don't tell me that that Cthulhu adaption was good just because it was in black and white and kind of looked 'thirties'. I don't buy it. Ultimately though, I'm of the opinion that adaptions, interpretations, remakes etc are all in their essence divorced from their ur-texts and should be just taken for what they are in themselves. This position helps me to enjoy even the likes of 'Dagon' (sorry, MTDS!) It also helps with 'From Beyond', which was of course Stewart Gordon's second stab at HPL after the heat of 'Reanimator'. It once again takes on a very lesser example of Lovecraft's work and gives it the souped up eighties horror treatment – lots of filters, heavy on effects, added salaciousness which would've had the old master leaping into an ice bath. 'From Beyond' works, but because of these latter aspects, not the Lovecraftian bits. It works as an efficient eighties B movie, well made and slick, with all the grue and over-the-topness genre fans had come to expect by then. It's the carnival in it that allures, not the prospect of pondering dark eternity. You want J Combs eating brains? You got it. Flesh melting transformations? You can have those, too. B Crampton in bondage gear? Yes, ma'am! On the other hand, do you want to get into something that makes you feel like a tiny, insignificant island of consciousness in a yawning abyss of uncertain and ambiguous dimension? Erm, can we get Barbara back in here, please? I recall that back in the day, or rather back in my uni days, 'From Beyond' had a bit of cachet as a come down tape. None of that 'deep' shit about it – if your head was mashed, you just wanted to see something with messed up monsters in it with a bit of something trippy going on in the background. In fact, with its disco light effects, talk of extending experience into the sensual beyond, warped transformations of self and deep recognition of universal consciousness and love (erm), 'From Beyond' strikes me now as nothing other than a refried Carpenterian 'The Thing' for the ecstasy generation. I'm lying, of course. It's nothing of the kind. It's just a cutely constructed, fast paced monster movie with latex and slime. And maybe Lovecraft wouldn't rent it for his late night Saturday jollies, but plenty would. |
| |||
Quote:
Sterling stuff Mr T.
__________________ [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC] [B] "... the days ahead will be filled with struggle ... and coated in marzipan ... "[/B] |
| ||||
Quote:
|
| ||||
Quote:
I also thing the HPL historical stuff is worth watching, both WHISPERER IN THE DARKNESS which plays like a classic era RKO picture and the silent CALL OF CTHULU are both worth watching. |
| ||||
Quote:
One weird thing I was thinking though - Sam Beckett has done loads of stage based AND film stuff, and he's at least as (anti-)metaphysical as Lovecraft. I know he's not a horror writer, but in one way it does make you wonder whether it's the restrictions of the medium or the confines of the genre which make Lovecraft adaptions so difficult to imagine. Ultimately though Lovecraft is defined by his literary style, which has no obvious cinematic equivalent. |
| ||||
ImageUploadedByTapatalk1438371423.609041.jpg Silly but very enjoyable fantasy film with Ferrigno in the title role takes some liberties with the source material but found it a lot better than Hercules in New York and even Conan . 7.5/10 ImageUploadedByTapatalk1438371747.842297.jpg Excellent, fantastic performances from a great cast in well made gothic thriller which is also very well directed with great period feel and uplifting twist ending. 9/10 Know watching this with I've not seen for years and later this weekend will watch the other two punisher movies which I've never seen. ImageUploadedByTapatalk1438372124.366549.jpg And will probably end the night with this, has anyone seen it? ImageUploadedByTapatalk1438372162.868823.jpg |
| ||||
Quote:
To adapt his stories, more often than not requires removing what makes them Lovecraft. |
Like this? Share it using the links below! |
| |